14120 Metropolis AvenueFort Myers, FL 33912

Insurance professionals that have your back


We are happy to assist you in selecting the best coverage.

Get a Quote


We get you the right coverage for the right price.

Get a Quote


We offer free quotes and dedicated personal service.

Get a Quote


February 17, 2019

Our company, Luxury Home Solutions, has various policies with Five County Insurance and we have worked with Mike Dannenhauer and his staff for over five years. Everyone at the company is very professional, knowledgeable and a pleasure to work with. The company excels in customer service and their rates are very competitive.

Five County Insurance also provides personalized, hands on policy reviews on a regular basis, pointing out areas where we can save premium dollars and/or suggestions for coverage changes that can help protect us.

We would highly recommend using Five County Insurance for peace of mind, knowing that you are fully covered, if the need arises.

January 3, 2019

Mike and his staff are truly amazing with their customer service and knowledge of the industry! I have been working with them for over 7 years with various policies and businesses and I could not ask for a better team. Everyone goes above and beyond to get you what you need when you need it. I wouldn’t dream of using anyone else for any of my insurance needs. If i could give them 10 stars I would! Thanks for all your hard work!

December 17, 2019

Five county has been taking care of my insurance needs for years, excellent company.

June 30, 2018

I just started working with Steve last year. Finally an honest Insurance Agency that actually helps me save money.

September 22, 2014

“Mike Dannenhauer and his team at Five County Insurance have been providing us with a variety of insurance products for the past two decades.  Mike’s responsiveness, knowledge and professionalism has served as the foundation for our successful long-term business relationship.  Further, his dedication to serving others extends beyond his company as he has volunteered thousands of hours to the building industry.  I am proud to do business with Mike and the Five County team.”

November 19, 2013

I have been working with Mike and the excellent staff at Five County Insurance since 1997.  Their representation for my asset management has been handled in a very professional manner and would not hesitate to recommend their services to my friends”.

Butch Ritter

Cape Coral Plumbing, Inc.

5812 Enterprise Pkwy.

Fort Myers, Fl. 33905



November 19, 2013

“When it comes to experience within insurance, Five County Insurance meets all our expectations. There staff off professionals are very knowledgeable in getting you the proper coverage where needed. Their attention to detail is second to none. Total Team Players “!

Steve Lawson
Director of Sales and Marketing
Advantage Plastering & Finish Carpentry INC

November 19, 2013

“We made a major move from Massachusetts to Florida and were unfamiliar with all resources. When we mentioned our frustration in obtaining information relevant to our insurance needs, our lawyer recommended Five County. After struggling to get information on various insurances and coverage with two other agents, Kathy Kalba at Five County gave us the information we requested in a professional, timely manner. More than that, she caught a mistake and saved us a lot of money. We had a very necessary, but complex issue, with fine arts insurance. She spent a lot of time ensuring that we had the best coverage we could obtain. We are in the process of using Five County as our agent in Florida for all our property and casualty insurances.”   

November 19, 2013

“Most of us who decide to call Florida home, assume that obtaining insurance is just a couple of phone calls looking for the best rates and giving our ok like we do in the other states. Not True! We had purchased a home in Cape Coral and called “our” insurance company back in Texas.  We were told “we don’t insure Florida”.  That was the beginning of our education.  I called another insurance carrier located in Florida and was told that I needed a roof inspection, window inspection, stucco inspection and if all was well, they would quote me a price.  That was the whole conversation, no explanation, nothing.  I assured him that that last time we saw the house, it had a roof, windows, and stucco and why did someone else need to verify that? Needless to say, we called Five County Insurance Agency and talked to Ms Christine Callari.  Christine explained everything to us in simple terms.  She gave us a few inspectors names to check out the house for us and answered any of our questions along the way.  Christine even contacted our financial institution when they had questions.  Someone is always available to help, I am not worried that we will be “dropped” as some of the insurance companies here are notorious for that, and when my husband decided to buy a boat, I had no trouble calling Christine and telling her that we needed more continuing education, and boat insurance!! ”   

November 15, 2013

Daniel Dannenhauer
Five County Insurance Agency, Inc.
14120 Metropolis Avenue
Forty Myers, FL 33912

Letter of Recommendation

“I’ve known Daniel Dannenhauer at Five County Insurance personally for nearly ten years, and he has acted as the Risk Manager for our Companies since 1987. Dan and his team have consistently taken a hands on proactive approach; they’ve taken the time to gain an understanding of our assets, operations, and the risks involved, insuring we’ve been provided the coverage needed across multiple business lines and a wide variety of operations.
Dan has worked to not only in securing us the best pricing, but has spent countless hours over the years on safety training and on identifying and correcting potential problems before they occur. All of this has lead to a safer work place for our employees and lower premiums for our firm. Five County has never been more than a phone call away anytime I’ve needed them and I truly can’t recommend Dan highly enough.”

John Greeley
The Bonita Bay Group